The suspension of point‑of‑capture shooting for trapped feral cats has sparked a fresh wave of petitions from residents and wildlife advocates who warn that the already fragile populations of the endemic Sister Islands rock iguana and the brown booby could slide toward local extinction without an effective culling method.
Why feral cats matter on the Sister Islands
Little Cayman (≈ 28 km²) and Cayman Brac host some of the Caribbean’s most vulnerable native fauna. The rock iguana (Cyclura nubila caymanensis)—a critically endangered subspecies—relies almost exclusively on Little Cayman for its remaining stronghold. Likewise, Little Cayman supports one of the Western Hemisphere’s largest red‑footed booby colonies, while Cayman Brac’s bluff is a historic nesting site for the brown booby (Sula leucogaster), a ground‑nesting seabird now teetering on the brink of local extinction.
Feral cats (Felis catus) are non‑native, free‑roaming predators that prey on juvenile iguanas and on eggs, chicks and nesting adults of ground‑nesting seabirds. Department of Environment (DoE) surveys have repeatedly identified feral‑cat predation as the principal cause of recruitment failure in rock iguanas and as a key factor behind the dramatic loss of brown‑booby fledglings on Cayman Brac.
The culling programme to date
A joint DoE–Department of Agriculture plan to eradicate or control feral cats in environmentally sensitive areas was first drafted in 2018. Legal challenges from animal‑welfare groups (Feline Friends Limited and the Cayman Islands Humane Society) halted the programme until a 2022 settlement that paid CI$25,000 in legal costs and required 100 % pet registration and microchipping on Little Cayman. After that, trapping resumed in June 2022; within the first six nights 40 cats were captured, four of which were micro‑chipped domestic pets returned to their owners.
In November 2025 the National Conservation Council (NCC) approved the Procedures for Controlling Feral Cats in Environmentally Sensitive Areas (2025), which authorized DoE staff to use high‑powered air rifles to shoot trapped cats at the point of capture. The same report recorded that, since 2022, 258 feral cats had been culled across the Sister Islands—209 on Little Cayman and 49 on Cayman Brac.
The impact of those removals is measurable. After an estimated 85 %–87 % of the feral‑cat population was eliminated between 2022 and 2025, the rock‑iguana count on Little Cayman rose from roughly 1,000 individuals in 2022 to about 3,500 in 2025—a three‑fold increase. Conversely, the brown‑booby colony on Cayman Brac has continued its long‑term decline: from 170 nesting pairs in the 1980s to just 22 pairs recorded in 2025, after a 70 % loss of eggs and chicks in the 2022 nesting season.
The October 2026 ministerial directive
On 2 October 2026, Sustainability and Environment Minister Katherine Ebanks‑Wilks announced in Parliament that the government had directed the DoE to stop using point‑of‑capture shooting in Little Cayman and in sensitive zones of Cayman Brac. The decision was framed as a response to concerns raised by animal‑welfare organisations about the humaneness of shooting cats while they remain in traps.
DoE Director Gina Ebanks‑Petrie clarified on 16 October that culling operations continue in those areas, but under alternative methods such as trap‑and‑transport to a veterinary facility for chemical euthanasia. The point‑of‑capture shooting ban therefore applies only to the air‑rifle technique approved in 2025.
Community and scientific pushback
Within days of the ministerial announcement, more than a dozen Little Cayman residents and conservation advocates sent formal letters to Minister Ebanks‑Wilks urging an immediate reversal of the shooting ban. Their core argument is that the alternative methods are logistically slower, more costly, and risk allowing surviving cats to re‑establish breeding colonies, thereby undoing the gains achieved since 2022.
“Every week we wait for a cat to be transported off the island, the next generation of iguanas and boobies is left exposed,” one petition signatory wrote. “If we lose the ability to kill cats instantly, the rock‑iguana population could fall back to pre‑cull numbers within a few breeding cycles.”
DoE Research Officer Simone Williams reinforced that warning, noting the brown‑booby numbers on Cayman Brac had already dropped to 22 nesting pairs in 2025 and that continued predation could lead to local extirpation. The 2025 NCC report warned that, without an efficient removal rate, feral‑cat numbers could rebound to levels that again suppress iguana recruitment.
Legal and political undercurrents
The culling controversy is not solely ecological. In February 2026, Feline Friends filed a fresh application for leave to seek judicial review (Cause No. G2026‑0047) against the DoE Director and the NCC, alleging that the point‑of‑capture shooting violated the Animals Act, the Firearms Act and the Penal Code. The charity also claimed that micro‑chipped companion cats had been mistakenly euthanized, contravening the settlement terms of 2022.
At a March 2026 NCC meeting, Secretary John Bothwell stated that no injunction or court order was in force against DoE operations while the judicial‑review application was pending. The DoE maintains that all captured domestic cats are identified via microchips and returned to owners, as documented during the 2022 trapping restart.
Political pressure added another layer. In September 2026, Opposition MP Chris Saunders (Bodden Town West) introduced a Private Member’s Bill to amend the National Conservation Act (NCA) so that “native species” could be re‑defined or feral cats exempted from invasive‑species culling. Saunders argued that “conservation should not be synonymous with killing,” and suggested a non‑lethal management approach.
Conservation scientists and NCC Chairman Dr Ian Kirkham rebutted the proposal, citing global research that ranks feral cats among the most damaging invasive predators. They warned that redefining cats as “native” would erode statutory protections for genuine endemic species and jeopardise decades of recovery effort for the rock iguana and seabirds.
Unresolved questions
- Ministerial response: As of 22 October 2026, Minister Ebanks‑Wilks has not issued a formal reply to the petition demanding reinstatement of the trap‑and‑shoot method.
- Effectiveness of alternative euthanasia: It remains unclear whether trap‑and‑transport and chemical euthanasia can achieve the same removal rate as point‑of‑capture shooting, especially in remote or rugged terrain.
- Brown‑booby fate: Ongoing monitoring during the 2026–2027 breeding season will reveal whether any nesting pairs survive on Cayman Brac or if the colony has been lost entirely.
- Court outcome: The Grand Court has yet to rule on Feline Friends’ February 2026 application for leave to seek judicial review. The decision will set a legal precedent for future invasive‑species control measures.
The stakes for the Sister Islands
The data paint a stark picture: effective feral‑cat removal has already produced a three‑fold increase in the rock‑iguana population on Little Cayman, while the brown‑booby colony on Cayman Brac continues its precipitous decline despite those gains. The suspension of point‑of‑capture shooting threatens to stall, or even reverse, the progress made over the past four years.
If the DoE cannot maintain a rapid, humane culling method, the rock iguana could regress toward its 2022 baseline of roughly 1,000 individuals, and the brown booby may disappear from Cayman Brac altogether. Both outcomes would represent not just a loss for the Cayman Islands’ natural heritage, but also for the broader Caribbean biodiversity that depends on these islands as critical breeding sites.
The coming weeks will test whether the Cayman government can balance animal‑welfare concerns with the urgent need to protect its most vulnerable native species. The answer will shape the ecological future of the Sister Islands for generations to come.