When the Toccoa River surged to a record‑breaking 18 feet on the night of November 4‑5, 2026, the small North‑Georgia town of McCaysville was inundated with six‑ to seven‑foot‑deep water that swept away cars, toppled a police cruiser and forced dozens of residents onto rooftops and porches. Among those stranded was Walmart employee Billy Paschall, who spent hours on his porch as floodwaters rose inside his rented home on Tennessee Avenue. Within four days, Paschall was able to return to the wrecked house and, after a series of desperate searches, locate all seven of his cats — a reunion he described as “a relief.”
The Flood That Shut Down McCaysville
McCaysville, perched on the banks of the Toccoa River (which becomes the Ocoee River across the Tennessee line), had barely recovered from a late‑summer flood earlier that year. According to Police Chief Michael Otis Earley, most municipal buildings and local businesses had only reopened a week before the November deluge. Heavy rain on November 4 triggered flash‑flood warnings for Fannin County, and the river crested at a historic 18 feet, according to FOX 5 Atlanta. In the downtown district, water rose to six or seven feet, submerging storefronts and even carrying a police cruiser downstream.
The flood’s rapid onset left many homeowners scrambling. Paschall, who had lived in the Tennessee Avenue rental for a decade, recalled that police officers knocked on his door in the early hours of November 5, urging him to pack a bag and evacuate. He managed to move one of his vehicles to higher ground, but when he returned for his truck the water was already too deep. He sealed his wallet, cellphone and keys in a Ziploc bag, opened his front door and watched floodwater pour into the house, eventually reaching “almost five feet or so” inside, per his later estimate.
Rescue by Boat and Immediate Aftermath
McCaysville’s emergency responders arrived by boat and lifted Paschall from his porch, where his cats had taken refuge atop small cat houses. He later said the officers “pulled his cats into the boat with him,” although subsequent reports differ on exactly how many felines were rescued that morning. A neighbor across the street agreed to care for two of the cats, while a three‑year‑old yellow female named Cricket remained missing.
Paschall was taken to an American Red Cross shelter in nearby Blue Ridge. There, CBS News Atlanta reporter Daniel Wilkerson interviewed him while he waited for assistance from his employer. Walmart supplied replacement clothing, shoes and a modest cash grant, which Paschall called “good as gold.” He also spoke with CBS meteorologist Orelon Sidney, who suggested placing a litter box outside the home to give the cats a familiar scent that might draw them back.
The Search for the Missing Cats
Over the next several days, Paschall and his neighbors scoured the flood‑damaged neighborhood. The litter‑box tip proved useful; six of the seven missing cats eventually returned on their own. On Monday, November 9, while CBS crews were filming the empty rooms of Paschall’s home, the final cat—a male named Bounce—was spotted, completing the reunion. Paschall’s reaction was simple and heartfelt: “It’s a relief.”
The exact path each cat took remains unclear. The November 5 report states that officers rescued some cats in the boat, while the November 10 story indicates all seven cats were missing after the flood and only returned later. The discrepancy leaves unanswered whether the two cats cared for by the neighbor escaped from the boat after it reached shore, or whether they were never in the boat at all. No further details were provided by officials or the news outlets.
Personal Losses and Ongoing Hardship
The flood destroyed virtually everything inside Paschall’s home. He reported losing “all of his household belongings” and three vehicles, with water flooding the interior to a depth of nearly five feet. The structural damage rendered the house uninhabitable, forcing Paschall to remain in the Red Cross shelter while he figured out next steps.
Because his home is still unsafe, Paschall said he plans to contact the Humane Society for help finding temporary foster care—or possibly permanent homes—for his seven cats. He emphasized that the cats are “my little girls” and “my little boy,” underscoring how integral the pets are to his sense of stability.
County‑wide Impact and Recovery Efforts
Paschall’s experience mirrors a broader picture of devastation across Fannin County. As of November 9‑10, the county Emergency Management Agency (EMA) public‑information officer Robert Poole reported that roughly 875 structures had been evaluated for damage, with about 20 more awaiting inspection in areas that were still cut off by flood‑damaged roads. The EMA confirmed that, to its knowledge, there were no deaths or injuries within Fannin County itself, though a former Cobb County deputy, Julie Barrs, died in neighboring Murray County when floodwaters swept her car away.
Highway 2 along Fightingtown Creek suffered severe damage, and tow crews from Allison Towing were still extracting submerged vehicles from the freezing creek. Koltyn Lucas, a tow‑operator, estimated that vehicle recovery could take several weeks.
The municipal water system in McCaysville was shut down during the flood. By early November, service had been restored, but a boil‑water advisory remained in effect for all customers on the McCaysville system, including those living outside city limits. Residents were instructed to flush pipes until water ran clear and to boil water before drinking or cooking. Susan Kiker, a local resident, said the water could be used for flushing toilets but that bottled or boiled water was still necessary for consumption.
State and local officials declared a state of emergency for McCaysville, and Governor Brian Kemp issued an emergency order. Several roadways—including Bushy Head Road—were restricted to one‑lane traffic, Ocoee River State Park was temporarily closed, and the Blue Ridge Scenic Railway suspended service for the weekend of November 7.
County officials also noted that many residents lack flood insurance, complicating recovery. Poole indicated that the county was still compiling damage assessments to determine whether it meets the threshold for a federal disaster declaration from FEMA. The final tally of destroyed or heavily damaged structures, and the decision on federal assistance, remain pending.
Unresolved Questions
While Paschall’s cat reunion offers a hopeful personal story amid widespread destruction, several uncertainties linger:
- Exact fate of each cat during the rescue: Conflicting accounts leave it unclear how many felines were taken aboard the rescue boat versus how many escaped on their own, and precisely when each of the six returning cats found its way back.
- Long‑term housing for Paschall and his pets: With his home deemed uninhabitable and no timeline for repairs, Paschall’s reliance on the Humane Society for temporary or permanent placement of his cats remains uncertain.
- County’s eligibility for FEMA aid: Because at least 20 structures still await inspection and some areas remain inaccessible, the final damage count—and whether it will trigger a federal disaster declaration—has yet to be determined.
- Duration of the boil‑water advisory: State water‑quality testing has not provided a definitive date for lifting the advisory, leaving residents to continue using bottled or boiled water.
These open issues underscore how the flood’s impact will reverberate for weeks, if not months, beyond the immediate rescue and reunion.