A Pennsylvania magistrate on Oct. 8, 2026 bound eight men incarcerated at the Allegheny County Jail to criminal‑homicide, conspiracy and kidnapping trials after surveillance footage placed them at the scene of fellow inmate Tyrone Good’s fatal assault on May 13, 2026.
The judge’s ruling
Magisterial District Judge Hillary Wheatley dismissed a single count of conspiracy to commit kidnapping for all defendants but kept the core homicide and kidnapping charges intact. Two of the accused—Kendall McKoy and Delvonte Woodson—also face tampering‑with‑evidence counts. The decision followed a full‑day preliminary hearing in the Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, during which prosecutors presented minute‑by‑minute video from the pod’s hallway cameras that tracked the men’s movements before, during and after the attack.
Victim and background
Tyrone Good, 44, was taken into custody in Atlanta on March 28, 2026 after an anonymous tip linked him to the Dec. 28, 2025 murder of his girlfriend, Michelle Sturdivant, in Pittsburgh’s Perry North neighborhood. He was extradited to Pennsylvania on April 15, 2026, arraigned on criminal‑homicide charges and held without bail at the Allegheny County Jail.
Who was charged
| Defendant | Age | Role in the incident |
|---|---|---|
| Kendall McKoy | 24 | Pod worker on Pod 4D; identified by prosecutors as the primary organizer |
| Justin Allen | 26 | Participant inside the victim’s cell |
| Delvonte Woodson | 20 | Participant; also charged with tampering evidence |
| Jerrell Rockymore | 19 | Participant |
| Mark Beavers | 27 | Gave a “thumbs‑up” signal to McKoy before the assault |
| Tavarius Lee | 20 | Participant |
| Shawn Davis | 23 | Entered the cell after the initial group, then shut the door |
| Anthony Schmitt | 24 | Entered the cell after the initial group, then shut the door |
All eight men were already serving sentences for other offenses when the May 13 incident occurred.
Timeline of the fatal assault
- 12:24 p.m. – 12:26 p.m. – Good is moved from restrictive housing to Pod 4D, entering Cell 116 with two clear bags of clothing.
- 12:26 p.m. – 12:43 p.m. – McKoy walks the pod, speaking with inmates on both upper and lower levels. Prosecutors described this as “rallying the troops.”
- 12:43 p.m. – Good’s cellmate leaves for lunch, leaving the cell door ajar.
- 12:44 p.m. – Beavers signals McKoy with a thumbs‑up.
- 12:45 p.m. – Six defendants (McKoy, Allen, Woodson, Rockymore, Beavers, Lee) enter Cell 116 together; Davis and Schmitt stand nearby.
- ~12:49 p.m. – Davis and Schmitt join the others inside, closing the door behind them.
- 12:50 p.m. – All eight exit the cell after roughly six and a half minutes inside.
- 12:58 p.m. – Good emerges from the cell covered in blood, collapses near the corrections officer’s desk, and is later pronounced dead at UPMC Mercy Hospital.
Surveillance cameras captured every movement in the hallway but do not record inside individual cells; consequently, no video directly shows the assault itself. Detectives testified that photos of the defendants’ clothing at the time of the incident were collected as physical evidence.
Legal arguments
Assistant District Attorney Matthew Goddard told the court that the eight men acted “in concert,” emphasizing McKoy’s role as the coordinator who moved through the pod “rallying the troops.” The defense collectively argued that mere presence in the victim’s cell did not prove participation in the homicide, seeking dismissal of all charges.
Judge Wheatley’s decision to keep the primary charges reflects the prosecution’s ability to link each defendant to the cell’s interior and to the timeline of the assault, even without interior video. The dismissal of the conspiracy‑to‑kidnap count suggests the judge found insufficient evidence of a coordinated plan to abduct Good beyond the homicide itself.
Alleged motive
County police and prosecutors contend the assault was a revenge killing. Good was accused of killing Michelle Sturdivant, who was the mother of Richard White—a close friend and former cellmate of McKoy. Jail communications cited by detectives show McKoy referring to White as “my best friend, my right hand.” The relationship between McKoy, White, and Sturdivant is presented as a possible catalyst for the attack.
Discrepancies and unanswered questions
Cause of death
Early media reports in May and June 2026 described Good as “stabbed to death,” while later coverage from the October hearing referred to the incident as a “beating death.” As of the preliminary hearing, the medical examiner’s final cause‑and‑manner‑of‑death report had not been entered into the public court record, leaving the exact mechanism of death unclear.
Guard oversight
A corrections officer was placed on unpaid leave in mid‑May 2026, but authorities have not disclosed the officer’s identity, exact duties, or whether negligence contributed to the six‑minute window in which eight inmates entered the victim’s cell. Advocacy groups have cited the incident to criticize staffing levels and monitoring practices in the jail’s maximum‑security pods.
Charge inconsistencies
Some early news outlets reported that all eight defendants faced tampering‑with‑evidence charges. Court filings, however, show that only McKoy and Woodson were formally charged with that additional offense.
Institutional response
The Allegheny County Police Department announced homicide and conspiracy charges on June 9, 2026. The jail’s administration initiated an internal review of pod security protocols, and the county’s oversight committee has scheduled a hearing to examine staffing and surveillance policies in response to the incident.
What remains to be resolved
The trial will need to determine whether the prosecution’s reliance on hallway video and circumstantial evidence can overcome the lack of interior footage. Additionally, the final medical examiner report will be crucial in confirming whether Good’s death resulted from blunt‑force trauma, stabbing, or a combination of injuries. The outcome may shape future policies on inmate monitoring, especially in high‑risk housing units where multiple inmates can congregate in a single cell.