A Hennepin County jury found 27‑year‑old Jose Luis Lopez Xique guilty of first‑degree premeditated murder, second‑degree intentional murder and harassment with a dangerous weapon for the June 2025 killing of 22‑year‑old Kayli Grace Arseth, who had rebuffed his attempts to turn a platonic friendship into a romance. Under Minnesota law the conviction carries a mandatory life‑without‑parole sentence, with formal sentencing set for October 15, 2026.
The Victim
Kayli Grace Arseth was a 22‑year‑old behavioral technician who worked with children who have special needs. Friends described her as an artist and motor‑bike enthusiast who loved painting, drawing, skateboarding and restoring motorcycles. Ten days before her death she announced plans to begin a degree in Developmental Psychology at the University of Minnesota, signaling a future focused on both personal growth and professional development.
The Defendant
Jose Luis Lopez Xique, born June 5, 1998, lived in Shakopee, Minnesota and served as a sergeant in the U.S. Army Reserve. He met Arseth on the dating app Hinge in May 2025. Their interaction remained non‑romantic; Arseth repeatedly made clear she was interested only in friendship. Despite this, Lopez Xique began a pattern of obsessive behavior, including repeatedly parking his car in the lot of Arseth’s apartment building to watch her.
Timeline of Events
May – Early June 2025: Courtship and Escalation
- May 2025 – Lopez Xique and Arseth matched on Hinge.
- May – June 2025 – Lopez Xique’s stalking intensified; he lingered in the parking lot of the Concierge Apartments (7710 Penn Ave South, Richfield) after her work shifts.
June 16, 2025: The Murder
- Afternoon – Lopez Xique purchased “murder kit” items at a local Walmart, including masking tape, gauze, rubber gloves, an apron, masks, sunglasses and cleaning wipes.
- ~4:26 p.m. – Arseth finished her shift and drove home.
- ~4:30 p.m. – Text messages show Arseth telling Lopez Xique she could not continue seeing him, even as a friend, and was not ready for a romantic relationship. Lopez Xique responded, asking to discuss it later.
- ~4:30 p.m. – 4:49 p.m. – Cell‑tower data places Lopez Xique’s phone at the apartment complex. A neighbor hears a woman shout, “How could you do this to me?” followed by a male voice and a loud bang.
- 4:49 p.m. – Lopez Xique’s phone leaves the complex.
- ~5:00 p.m. – A friend arrives to pick Arseth up for evening plans; receives no answer and departs around 5:30 p.m., later contacting Arseth’s father.
- Evening – Lopez Xique discards the Walmart‑bought supplies in a trash bin a few blocks from the apartment; park workers later recover the items.
June 17 – July 7 2025: Discovery and Arrest
- June 17 – Arseth fails to report to work. Her mother requests a welfare check; police enter the locked unit and find Arseth face‑down on the living‑room floor with a gunshot wound to the head.
- July 3 – Richfield police arrest Lopez Xique near his Shakopee home.
- July 7 – Prosecutors charge Lopez Xique with second‑degree intentional murder; bail is set at $2.5 million. The charge is later elevated to include first‑degree premeditated murder.
September 28 – October 9 2026: Trial and Verdict
- September 28 – The trial opens in Hennepin County District Court.
- Early October – The Minnesota Supreme Court issues a ruling on the admissibility of alternative‑perpetrator evidence, prompting a defense motion for a mistrial.
- October 9 – The jury returns guilty verdicts on all counts.
Evidence That Secured the Conviction
- Forensic Scene Findings – No forced entry was observed; doors and windows were locked. Blood spatter on the interior door frame and a close‑range head wound, determined by the Hennepin County Medical Examiner, indicated the shooter was in intimate proximity to the victim. DNA from the recovered firearm matched Lopez Xique.
- Surveillance and Purchases – Walmart security footage confirmed Lopez Xique bought the cleaning and concealment supplies hours before the killing. The discarded items recovered from a public trash receptacle matched the purchase receipt.
- Digital Footprints – Text messages documented Arseth’s clear rejection on the day of the murder. Cell‑tower and GPS data placed Lopez Xique at the apartment during the critical 4:30 p.m.–4:49 p.m. window, aligning with the neighbor’s eyewitness account.
- Eyewitness Testimony – A resident reported hearing a woman’s anguished shout followed by a male voice and a gunshot, corroborating the timeline derived from digital evidence.
Competing Theories Presented at Trial
- Prosecution Narrative – Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty framed the killing as a calculated “rejection murder,” driven by Lopez Xique’s inability to accept Arseth’s refusal and his pre‑meditation, as evidenced by the purchase of cleanup supplies and the absence of forced entry.
- Defense Argument – Lopez Xique’s counsel claimed his presence at the apartment was incidental, suggesting he was acting as a “protective security guard” and that the prosecution had not proven intent. The defense also sought to introduce evidence of an ex‑boyfriend’s prior threats toward Arseth, a line of inquiry the court ultimately limited.
Legal Nuances and Ongoing Appeals
The mid‑trial Minnesota Supreme Court decision on alternative‑perpetrator evidence created a procedural foothold for the defense, which filed a motion for a mistrial and signaled an intention to raise the issue on appeal after sentencing. While the court allowed the trial to proceed, legal analysts anticipate that the defense may argue the jury was improperly restricted from hearing potentially exculpatory testimony concerning Arseth’s past relationships.
Official Reactions
Mary Moriarty, Hennepin County Attorney, issued a statement on October 9, 2026 expressing sympathy for Arseth’s family and condemning the “rejection killing” as a “horrifying instance” of possessive violence. She highlighted Arseth’s love of music, art, and her work with children, underscoring the loss to the community.
Unresolved Questions
The case has raised broader concerns about “rejection killings” and the role of digital communication in escalating obsessive behavior. While the conviction stands, the upcoming appeal may test the limits of evidence admissibility in cases where prior relationship dynamics are contested. How courts balance a defendant’s right to present alternative narratives with the need to protect victims from intimate‑partner violence remains an evolving legal frontier.