← Back to articles

New Cat Food Study Finds Heavy Metals Widespread and Highlights Sharp Differences by Protein Source

Updated 2026-11-02

Article cover

The Clean Label Project’s 2026 Cat Food Category Report, released on October 2, 2026, tested 100 top‑selling cat foods from 62 brands for more than 122 contaminants. Lead appeared in 99 percent of the samples, and the type of protein—poultry versus fish—proved to be the strongest predictor of heavy‑metal levels, with fish‑based recipes showing dramatically higher mercury, cadmium and arsenic than their poultry counterparts.


Scope and Methodology

The study examined 100 products that dominate U.S. cat‑food sales, including 40 wet (canned or pouched), 31 dry kibble, and 29 air‑ or freeze‑dried formulas. Samples were bought from retail outlets and analyzed at an ISO 17025‑accredited laboratory.

Unlike the organization’s earlier dog‑food report, which compared wet and dry foods by weight, the cat‑food analysis converted all results to a per‑1,000‑kilocalorie basis. This adjustment accounts for the wide range in moisture content (wet foods can contain more than 75 % water) and avoids the misleading impression that high‑moisture foods are automatically “cleaner.”

The Clean Label Project (CLP) created a proprietary “purity standard” that aggregates contaminant scores across six panels. Products that met the threshold were placed on two “Clean Sixteen” lists—one for wet foods and one for dry/freeze‑dried foods. CLP did not disclose raw concentration values for individual brands, nor did it publish a “fail list.” Instead, it highlighted the best‑performing items and announced three brands that received its paid Purity Awards or certifications.


Heavy‑Metal Findings

Detection Frequency

Protein Source as the Dominant Factor

When CLP grouped the foods by primary animal protein, the contrast was stark:

Protein type% meeting purity standard
Poultry‑based84.8 %
Fish/seafood‑based25.7 %

Fish‑based recipes carried roughly 18 times more mercury than non‑fish foods on a per‑1,000‑kcal basis. In the wet‑food segment, fish formulas contained about 28 times more mercury than wet foods made from other proteins. Cadmium and arsenic showed similar, though less extreme, patterns—fish products averaged about 2.5 times the cadmium of non‑fish foods.

Lead, by contrast, appeared across formats and protein types. Dry kibble carried about three times more lead than wet or freeze‑dried foods after caloric adjustment, a difference the report linked to processing and to the higher proportion of plant‑derived fillers in many dry formulas.

Format Differences


Other Contaminants

Glyphosate and Ingredient “Splitting”

Glyphosate, the widely used herbicide, showed up in 37 % of the tested foods, with its breakdown product AMPA in 12 %. CLP observed a linear relationship between the number of plant ingredients listed among the first ten label items and glyphosate levels: each additional plant ingredient raised the measured glyphosate by roughly 40 %.

The report also highlighted “ingredient splitting,” where the named meat or fish appears first but is outnumbered by plant components in the top ten ingredients. This practice was present in 35 % of the products and correlated with higher lead concentrations.

Phthalates and Bisphenols

Acrylamide

Abyssal to high‑temperature extrusion, acrylamide was measurable in 4 % of the samples and at trace levels in an additional 24 %. The report did not link these low levels to any specific health concerns.


The “Clean Sixteen” Lists

To give consumers a concrete guide, CLP compiled two unranked lists of the 16 lowest‑contaminant products in each format. The wet‑food list included familiar names such as Applaws Chicken Breast & Duck in Broth, Freshpet Tender Chicken & Garden Vegetable, Purina Fancy Feast Grilled Turkey Feast in Gravy, and Smalls Smooth Bird Chicken. The dry/freeze‑dried list featured brands like Green Juju Duck & Sardine, Smallbatch Freeze‑Dried Turkey Bites, and Weruva Paw Lickin’ Chicken Freeze‑Dried.

In a separate announcement, CLP highlighted three brands that have earned its paid Purity Awards or certifications: Bixbi, Freshpet, and Smalls. Smalls, a direct‑to‑consumer brand, reported on October 14‑15 that nine of its cat‑food recipes now carry CLP recognition, including a “Smooth Fish” recipe that passed the purity threshold despite the overall trend of higher mercury in fish‑based foods.


Industry Reaction

Pet Food Institute (PFI) Pushback

The trade group representing cat‑food manufacturers issued a formal response on October 9, 2026. PFI argued that CLP’s findings “lack the scientific and regulatory context needed to interpret them.” The institute emphasized that modern analytical equipment can detect trace amounts of naturally occurring elements, and that detection alone does not equate to toxicity. PFI also criticized CLP for omitting absolute concentration values (e.g., parts per million) and for not comparing results to the safety limits set by the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) or the National Research Council (NRC).

Veterinary Perspective

Veterinary nutritionists echoed similar concerns. In an October 6 commentary, a board‑certified veterinary dietitian noted that the report’s relative multipliers (“3 × more lead,” “18 × more mercury”) are meaningless without the actual numbers and without reference to established maximum tolerable levels. The commentator also warned that focusing on trace detections could distract pet owners from more pressing nutritional considerations.

Independent Analysts

Some observers praised the study’s breadth. Ryan Babadi, science director of the nonprofit Toxic Free Future, called the analysis “reasonably conducted” and urged major retailers to demand cleaner ingredients and packaging, especially for chemicals already being phased out in other consumer products.


Points of Contention

  1. Detection vs. Health Risk – The core scientific dispute centers on whether the presence of parts‑per‑billion quantities of heavy metals poses a real danger to cats. Regulatory agencies set maximum tolerable levels that consider chronic exposure, bioavailability, and species‑specific sensitivity. CLP’s report does not present its measurements alongside those thresholds, leaving the risk assessment ambiguous.

  2. Transparency of Raw Data – By keeping the raw contaminant numbers private and only publishing aggregate pass/fail outcomes, CLP limits independent verification. Critics argue that this approach benefits the organization’s commercial certification program, which charges brands for the “Purity” label.

  3. Impact of Moisture Adjustment – While CLP’s shift to a per‑kilocalorie metric is a methodological improvement over its earlier dog‑food study, some analysts note that the conversion still relies on labeled caloric values, which can vary between batches and may not reflect actual energy content.

  4. Packaging Contributions – The detection of DEHP primarily in canned and pouched foods suggests a potential migration route, yet the study stops short of confirming it. Without targeted migration testing, the link remains speculative.


Consumer Takeaways


Unresolved Question

The study underscores a broader gap in the pet‑food industry: the lack of publicly available, standardized contaminant limits for heavy metals and other chemicals in cat nutrition. As CLP’s findings spark consumer concern, regulators, manufacturers, and independent labs will need to decide whether to establish mandatory reporting thresholds or to rely on voluntary certifications. Until such standards are in place, pet owners must navigate a landscape where detection does not automatically translate into risk, and where commercial interests may shape the narrative around safety.


References:

www.petfoodindustry.com

rinewstoday.com

cleanlabelproject.org

petful.com

cnn.com

cleanlabelproject.org

einpresswire.com

cleanlabelproject.org

petfoodindustry.com

youtube.com

reddit.com

petfoodindustry.com

petfoodinstitute.org

petfoodindustry.com

petfoodindustry.com

cleanlabelproject.org

cleanlabelproject.org

thecatchaddy.com

einpresswire.com

vetdrlan.com

Explore more articles →Page views: 23