Authorities in Lackawanna County, Pennsylvania, entered a vacant house on Ontario Street in the unincorporated community of Simpson on November 9‑10, 2026, and removed 40 living cats and the remains of two dead cats. The operation, led by the county district attorney’s office, the humane officer, and volunteers from Griffin Pond Animal Shelter, is being treated as an animal‑cruelty investigation, but no charges have yet been filed.
A vacant house, a foul odor, and growing concern
Neighbors had long complained that the empty residence on Ontario Street emitted a strong smell of cat urine and ammonia. Jerry Tregaskis, who lives nearby, said the odor was “hell” in the summer and that it made outdoor gatherings impossible. He also reported seeing an unidentified woman occasionally entering the house with bags of cat litter. The property had been vacant for several months, according to local accounts, and the stench was noticeable from the street.
The investigation begins
On Monday, November 9, 2026, the Lackawanna County District Attorney’s Office officially opened an animal‑cruelty investigation at the Simpson home. Deputy District Attorney Mike McGrath explained that the humane officer and volunteers from Griffin Pond Animal Shelter would be the first responders inside the house. Because of the high ammonia levels, all personnel wore protective gear.
The team set humane traps baited with food and began coaxing the cats into cages. By the end of the day they had captured eight living cats and discovered the bodies of two dead cats. WNEP’s initial report, posted at 3:03 PM EST, detailed these early numbers and noted that the extraction could take several days.
Scaling up the rescue
Rescue crews returned on Tuesday, November 10, 2026, and continued trapping throughout the afternoon. By the time the day ended, the total count rose to 40 living cats, in addition to the two deceased felines found earlier. All 40 survivors were taken into the custody of Griffin Pond Animal Shelter for veterinary assessment. The updated figure was confirmed by the district attorney’s office and reported by WNEP at 4:44 PM EST.
Deputy DA McGrath described the process:
“It’s going to be just caging and offering food, see if they can coax them into the cages, and then there’ll be an assessment made on each animal to ascertain the overall physical conditions and what kind of state they’re in.”
He added that the operation could extend for days until officials were certain no cats remained hidden inside the structure.
Who is involved
- Lackawanna County District Attorney’s Office – Leads the criminal investigation. Deputy District Attorney Mike McGrath serves as the public spokesperson.
- Lackawanna County Humane Officer – Works alongside shelter volunteers to secure the animals and collect evidence. County records identify the officer as Marci Zeiler, though the WNEP report referred to the role generically.
- Griffin Pond Animal Shelter – Located at 967 Griffin Pond Road in South Abington Township, the shelter provided volunteers, equipment, and the cages used to capture the cats. All rescued animals are now under its care for medical evaluation.
- Local residents – Neighbors, including Jerry Tregaskis, supplied early warnings about the odor and reported sightings of a woman delivering litter.
Legal context
Pennsylvania’s animal‑cruelty statutes, often called “Libre’s Law,” categorize offenses into three tiers:
- Neglect of an animal – Failure to provide basic care; generally a misdemeanor.
- Cruelty to an animal – Intentional or reckless mistreatment; also a misdemeanor.
- Aggravated cruelty – Acts that cause death or serious bodily injury; a third‑degree felony punishable by up to seven years in prison and a $15,000 fine per count.
Because two cats were found dead, prosecutors will likely rely on veterinary necropsies to determine whether the deaths resulted from neglect or intentional cruelty, which could elevate the case to aggravated cruelty. As of the November 10 update, the district attorney’s office had not announced any charges.
Strain on local shelter resources
The Simpson case adds to a recent pattern of large‑scale hoarding incidents in Lackawanna County that have stretched the capacity of Griffin Pond and other local rescues.
- April 2026 – South Scranton hoarding – Police discovered 31 live cats and 76 dead cats in a condemned home. The suspect, Mark Aaron Yasawik, was charged with multiple felony and misdemeanor counts. Griffin Pond and the volunteer group Street Cats and Dogs provided emergency care for the surviving felines.
- September 2024 – “Self‑described rescue” seizure – Over 100 cats were removed from a residential property after the ASPCA was called in to assist local authorities. Many animals had to be shipped out of state for treatment because local facilities were overwhelmed.
- September 2026 – State funding for humane law enforcement – Pennsylvania Senator Marty Flynn helped secure a $43,860 grant for a Griffin Pond humane‑officer vehicle, underscoring the growing need for dedicated resources.
These precedents illustrate why the Simpson rescue, while smaller than the Scranton hoarding, still represents a significant operational challenge for the shelter and law‑enforcement teams.
Unanswered questions
Several critical details remain unclear:
- Ownership of the property – Authorities have not identified the legal owner of the vacant house or explained why it remained uninhabited while cats were kept inside.
- Identity of the woman seen with litter – The neighbor’s observation of a woman delivering cat litter has not been confirmed or linked to any suspect.
- Final animal count – Deputy DA McGrath warned that the trapping could take days; it is not yet known whether any cats remain hidden in the house.
- Medical findings – Veterinary assessments of the 40 rescued cats and necropsy results for the two dead cats have not been released, leaving the exact health impacts and causes of death undisclosed.
- Potential charges – No criminal charges have been filed as of the latest report. Prosecutors are still evaluating whether the evidence meets the threshold for felony aggravated cruelty.
What comes next
The rescued cats are undergoing veterinary examinations at Griffin Pond, after which the shelter will decide on adoption placements, long‑term foster care, or, if necessary, euthanasia for animals deemed unsalvageable. The district attorney’s office will continue its investigation, likely consulting veterinary reports to determine the appropriate legal classification of the alleged abuse.
If charges are eventually filed, the case could become another example of Pennsylvania’s increasingly stringent enforcement of animal‑cruelty laws, especially in situations where large numbers of animals are subjected to unsanitary, hazardous conditions.