A September 8, 2024 decision by the British Columbia Civil Resolution Tribunal (CRT) forced the owners of Strata Plan KAS1677—a 64‑unit condominium at 920 Saskatoon Road in Kelowna—to grant resident Debbie Eaton an exemption allowing her emotional support cat to remain in her unit and to cancel all pet‑related fines that had been levied against her.
Eaton, who purchased a unit in the building despite two prior denials of her request to keep a cat, presented medical documentation confirming a diagnosis of moderate major depressive disorder. The CRT concluded that the strata’s strict “no‑pets” bylaw, which only permits a “properly trained” animal prescribed by a physician, discriminated against her under Section 8 of the B.C. Human Rights Code. The tribunal found no evidence of undue hardship and rejected the council’s arguments that Eaton had waived her rights by completing the purchase.
The Strata By‑law and Eaton’s Requests
Strata Plan KAS1677’s bylaws prohibit all pets, with a narrow exception for “one properly trained animal … prescribed by a physician and approved by the Strata Council in writing to assist a resident or visitor with a disability.”
- Pre‑purchase attempts: Before buying her unit, Eaton formally applied twice for an exemption to keep her cat. Both applications were rejected, yet she proceeded with the purchase.
- May 2024 medical evidence: A registered clinical counsellor supplied a letter stating that Eaton’s emotional support cat was medically necessary for a mental‑health disorder listed in the DSM. A subsequent physician’s letter confirmed a diagnosis of moderate major depressive disorder and noted symptom remission after acquiring the cat.
Despite this documentation, the council maintained its denial, arguing that the cat was not “trained or certified” and that allowing the animal would cause undue hardship for residents with allergies.
CRT Findings on Key Arguments
| Issue | Strata Council’s Position | CRT’s Determination |
|---|---|---|
| Proof of disability | No sufficient evidence of a recognized disability. | The physician’s diagnosis satisfied the Human Rights Code’s definition of a mental‑health disability. |
| Animal certification | The cat lacked formal training or certification required by the bylaw. | B.C. law does not mandate certification for emotional support animals; the bylaw’s wording was interpreted in light of the Human Rights Code. |
| Undue hardship | Granting an exemption would burden owners with animal allergies. | The strata offered no medical proof that any resident’s health would be impaired; the claim was rejected. |
| Waiver of rights | Purchasing the unit after prior denials implied acceptance of the pet ban. | The tribunal ruled that buying the condo did not waive Eaton’s statutory rights under the Human Rights Code. |
The CRT explicitly stated that the law “does not support” the argument that Eaton forfeited her accommodation rights by completing the purchase.
Orders Issued
- Bylaw exemption: Strata Plan KAS1677 must allow Eaton to keep her emotional support cat in her unit.
- Reversal of fines: All pet‑related fines assessed to Eaton—levied at $200 per week for alleged bylaw violations—must be cancelled and any collected amounts returned.
The decision did not specify a total dollar amount for the fines, only that the weekly rate was $200.
How This Ruling Fits Within Provincial Precedent
B.C.’s Strata Property Act permits strata corporations to adopt pet restrictions, but Section 8 of the Human Rights Code overrides those restrictions when a resident demonstrates a disability‑related need. The CRT’s approach varies according to the strength of medical evidence and any demonstrated safety concerns.
- Permitted support animals: In Schlosser/Lenius v. Strata (May 2022), the CRT allowed a resident to keep three emotional support cats after receiving letters from a social worker and two physicians confirming a generalized anxiety disorder.
- Insufficient evidence: In Khan v. Strata Plan (April 8 2025), the tribunal upheld fines because the owner’s doctor notes were “vague” and did not explain why three cats were required.
- Safety overrides accommodation: An August 2024 case involving an emotional support dog that attacked other animals resulted in the animal’s removal, though the strata had to refund $11,800 in fines for procedural failures.
Eaton’s case aligns with the first precedent—clear medical documentation establishing a mental‑health disability—while the council’s claim of undue hardship was dismissed due to a lack of concrete evidence.
Unresolved Issues
- Total fine amount: News reports confirm the $200‑per‑week rate but have not disclosed the cumulative sum that was reversed.
- Potential appeal: No information has been released about whether Strata Plan KAS1677 intends to challenge the CRT’s decision through a court review.
These gaps leave open the possibility of further legal maneuvering, which could shape how future strata‑resident disputes over emotional support animals are resolved.