← Back to articles

If You Can’t Commit to a Cat the Way You Would a Dog, Don’t Get One

Updated 2026-11-03

Article coverImage source

Prospective cat owners often assume that a feline’s famed independence means the animal can be left outside or ignored when it doesn’t behave like a dog. Retired LAPD Sergeant Mike Barone argues that this misconception endangers cats, strains neighborhoods, and should be addressed with clear municipal containment rules.


Cats are not miniature dogs. Their instincts, social needs and vulnerability to everyday hazards differ dramatically from those of canines. Barone’s three‑decade personal chronicle—spanning a rescued injured cat in 2009, a second indoor‑only companion adopted in 2019, and a third stray that now visits his backyard—illustrates why “cat‑friendly” policies must match the responsibility demanded of dog owners.

The Real Risks of Free‑Roaming Cats

Barone treats a domestic cat’s inability to assess danger as comparable to a young child’s lack of understanding. He recounts that, in his own Los Angeles neighborhood, three cats have been killed by coyotes and several more have been run over. The 2009 shooting of his first rescue cat underscores a more deliberate threat: some people actively harm free‑roaming cats.

Beyond predation and traffic, outdoor cats face disease, fights with other cats, and the ecological impact of hunting birds and small wildlife. Residents frequently post missing‑cat alerts on neighborhood forums and Ring camera groups, turning a private loss into a community concern.

Why Owners Misread Feline Behavior

Many people acquire cats expecting the constant companionship typical of dogs. When a cat chooses to nap alone, ignores a call, or simply walks away, disappointed owners may interpret the behavior as “ungrateful” and move the animal outdoors. Barone points out that this expectation ignores the species‑specific social structures of felines.

Veterinary experts echo this view. A 2026 Newsweek interview with Dr. Liza Cahn emphasized that cats have distinct communication styles and do not thrive under the same training regimes as dogs. While cat owners may report lower levels of overt affection compared with dog owners, they often experience reduced stress and anxiety—benefits tied to a cat’s quieter presence rather than overt clinginess.

Barone’s message is clear: a cat’s aloofness does not equal neglect. “A cat is not a dog that happens to meow,” he writes. “If you cannot commit to a cat like you would a dog, do not get a cat.”

A Call for Municipal Containment Laws

Drawing on his 23 years of law‑enforcement experience, Barone proposes that cities adopt ordinances that treat cat containment with the same seriousness as dog leash laws. His policy suggestions include:

Barone argues that the current legal landscape in Los Angeles is inconsistent. The city’s leash law explicitly exempts cats, and the county code contains no comparable restriction. While the Los Angeles Animal Services program funds TNR and encourages indoor housing for owned cats, there is no enforcement mechanism to deter owners from letting pets roam.

What the Data Says About Indoor vs. Outdoor Living

Veterinary literature consistently shows that indoor cats live longer than those that spend most of their lives outside. Sources such as Whitesburg Animal Hospital and the Catellect blog cite average indoor lifespans of 12‑18 years, often reaching 20 years, versus 5‑7 years for outdoor‑only cats.

A 2023 mortality study from UC Davis found that intact outdoor cats die significantly younger than spayed or neutered cats, with median ages of death under five years for intact animals. The same study reported no statistically significant lifespan difference between indoor‑only cats and those with limited outdoor access, suggesting that a secure, supervised outdoor environment does not necessarily reduce longevity.

Conversely, a two‑year field study of 42 pet and stray cats in Minnesota highlighted overlapping territories between owned roaming cats and feral populations, leading to higher rates of infectious disease and injuries from fights. These findings reinforce Barone’s point that free‑roaming owned cats contribute to both personal and community health risks.

Cultural and Practical Obstacles

The debate over cat containment is not purely scientific; it reflects deep cultural differences. In many European and UK households, cat flaps and free‑range access are the norm, with owners citing mental stimulation, natural hunting behavior, and obesity prevention as benefits. In contrast, Australian and increasingly American municipalities are moving toward indoor‑only mandates to protect wildlife and reduce cat mortality.

Enforcement poses a practical challenge. Distinguishing an owned, free‑roaming cat from a feral animal often requires a microchip scan, which is rarely feasible for animal‑control officers. Barone’s proposal therefore includes a “reasonable proof” clause, allowing owners to demonstrate microchip registration or other evidence of responsible ownership before fines are levied.

The Ongoing Story of Barone’s Third Visitor

At the time of his November 2, 2026 column, a young male cat had begun visiting Barone’s backyard. Because Barone’s indoor cat needed protection from potential disease, he could not bring the newcomer inside immediately. Instead, he built an insulated outdoor shelter, provided food and water, and coordinated with a local rescue worker to arrange neutering and veterinary care. The cat’s ultimate fate—whether it will become a permanent indoor resident, remain an outdoor companion, or fall victim to the hazards Barone warns about—remains unknown.

Implications for Future Policy

Barone’s commentary raises a pivotal question: Should municipalities treat cats with the same legal responsibility as dogs, or does the species’ unique nature demand a different approach? As urban wildlife conservation gains momentum and public safety concerns about free‑roaming pets intensify, the pressure to harmonize animal‑welfare standards with community health will likely increase. Whether Los Angeles or other jurisdictions will adopt Barone’s containment proposals remains to be seen, but the growing body of veterinary evidence and the personal stories of owners like Barone suggest that the conversation is far from over.


References:

citywatchla.com

citywatchla.com

citywatchla.com

citywatchla.com

newsweek.com

dimensionwerks3d.com

latimes.com

zcla.org

laanimalservices.com

lacity.org

lacounty.gov

whitesburganimalhospital.com

catellect.com

furryfriendsrefuge.org

aercmn.com

economictimes.com

ucdavis.edu

nih.gov

Explore more articles →Page views: 14